Historical Background On The Phenomenon
Using context to understand why hackers set out to build digital currency systems.
Satoshi Nakamoto was the first participant in his own network, and left a message within the very first “block” of data produced by Bitcoin. The message within this so-called Genesis Block read
The original headline appears in the British paper The Times (see figure below). The inclusion of this note is a source of widespread confusion.
Given what we know about Nakamoto’s motivation to create a free economic space outside the purview of institutional oversight, it would seem that this message makes light of the sympathetic relationship between politicians and central bankers. Many people use this allusion to infer that Bitcoin was purpose-built as some kind of disruptor or destroyer of central banks. Taken this way, the headline would seem to be a statement of superiority or self-righteousness.
We suggest that this is a mischaracterization. If Bitcoin does evolve into a large-scale alternative currency system, then Nakamoto’s use of The Times headline will strike historians as timely, but it is more than just a political statement.
In fact, putting a headline in the Genesis Block has a second, more practical purpose: it serves as a timestamp. By reproducing the text from that day’s paper, Nakamoto proved that the first “block” of data produced by the network was indeed made that day, and not prior. Nakamoto knew Bitcoin was a new kind of network that prospective participants would scarcely believe was real. At the outset, it would be important to send a signal of integrity to people who might join. Getting volunteers to value the project was top priority, indeed a far higher priority than mocking central bankers.
For investors outside the technology industry, understanding this volunteer-based way of working is critical to understanding why Bitcoin operates the way it does, and why it is an improvement on conventional methods of human collaboration. To get to these points, we will first explore the origins of the “war” that Satoshi is engaged in, and how the invention of Bitcoin is meant to change the tide.
The old friction between technologists and management
For the last 50 years, corporate technology companies are increasingly at odds with the engineers that build their critical systems. Recent headlines tell the story: at Microsoft, Amazon, and Salesforce, employees protested contracts with Customs and Border Patrol and ICE. At Google, employees protested the company’s Project Maven AI contracts for the Department of Defense, which promised to increase the accuracy of drone strikes; it bowed out from Project Maven, but has said it will continue to work with the US military in other projects. Google’s announcement that it would agree to censor search results inside China drew 1400 workers to protest. Microsoft is facing a lawsuit by two employees who may have suffered PTSD after seeing ***** *****ography as part of “content moderation” roles. YouTube employees describe their jobs as a “daily hell of ethics debate.” Facebook has experienced protests for the gentrification wrought by its tens of thousands of employees, as well as more recent protests for its “intolerant” political culture.
Other *****s of technological systems include the personal data leak at Equifax, and the ***** of account-creation privileges within the Wells Fargo bank computer system, where accounts were opened and cards issued—in some cases, with forged signatures—in service of sales goals. The worst example of abusive corporate software systems might be the maker of the automated sentencing software employed by some court systems, called COMPAS, which has been shown to recommend prison terms based on the convict’s race.
Tensions between software developers and their employers have spilled out of Silicon Valley and into mainstream news. “This engineer’s lament is a microcosm of a larger trend sweeping across the Peninsula” of San Francisco, reported Vanity Fair in August of 2018:
“In Silicon Valley’s halcyon days, employees didn’t have any qualms about the ethics of the companies they were joining since many honestly believed that they were going to advance a corporation that was going to—yes—change the world. The people who helped transform the Bay Area into the greatest wealth-generation machine in human history—and themselves into millionaires and billionaires in the process—are now turning their backs on the likes of hegemonic corporations who, in their own depictions, moved fast and broke things without an end in sight.”
The article quotes an anonymous Uber executive who fears that ethical issues will motivate engineers to leave en masse: “If we can’t hire any good engineers, we’re *****ed.”
This is a liminal moment in business, where the “good engineers” suddenly have leverage over the wealthy and elite management of some of the largest corporations in the history of the world. This development did not arrive overnight; it has its origins in a tension that originated decades ago.
Next, we will look at how the balance of power shifted, and how Bitcoin tips the scale further for the “good engineers.” To appreciate how the software engineers got their leverage, we must begin in the early 20th century, and learn how managers and engineers got to be at odds in the first place.
The emergence of the corporate institution (1900-1929)
The study of human behavior in a business context has a rich tradition. Perhaps the first person to take a meaningful step forward in this discipline was Frederick Winslow Taylor. “Taylorism,” his conception of management science, was all about rational planning, reducing waste, analyzing data, and standardizing best practices. Business owners used these techniques to drive workers uncommonly hard. Andrew Carnegie obsessed over worker productivity, becoming so frustrated with the Homestead Strike of 1892 that he hired a private police force to have picketing workers shot.
Thorstein Veblen was a Norwegian-American economist who published his seminal study of practitioners of management science in 1904. He created a series of insights about the nature of “institutions,” as distinct from the “technologies” used by them. This distinction is a good starting point for understanding the problems that arise for people who create new technologies within institutions.
An important aspect of Veblen's concept of "institution" is that they are by nature non-dynamic—they resist changes that don’t benefit the top people in the hierarchical structure. Hierarchy persists through what Veblen called “ceremonial aspects,” traditional privileges that served to elevate the decision-makers. It is new technological tools and processes which make the institution profitable. But so-called “spurious” tools may be also be produced because they have ceremonial aspects that make management look or feel good.
After the Great Depression, the historian and sociologist Lewis Mumford would develop the idea that “technology” had a dual nature. Polytechnic developments involved complex frameworks which combined technologies to solve real human problems; Monotechnic developments were technology for its own sake. Monotechnics oppress human beings, Mumford argued, citing the automobile as one such development that crowded out pedestrians and bicyclists from roads, and led to a massive annual death toll on American highways.
The institutions of the day, corporations and governments, Mumford called megamachines. Megamachines, he said, are comprised of many human beings, each with a specialized role in a larger bureaucracy. He called these individuals “servo units.” Mumford argued that for these people, the specialized nature of the work weakened psychological barriers against questionable commands from leadership, because each individual was responsible for only one small aspect of the machine’s overall goal. At the top of a megamachine sat a corporate scion, dictator, or commander to whom god-like attributes were attributed. He cited the lionization of Egyptian Pharaohs and Soviet dictators as examples.
Ceremonial, spurious, monotechnic developments could lead to extremely deadly megamachines, said Mumford, as in the case of the Nazi War Machine. This phenomenon owed itself to the abstraction of the work into sub-tasks and specialties (such as assembly line work, radio communications). This abstraction allowed the servo-units to work on extreme or heinous projects without ethical involvement, because they only comprised one small step of the larger process. Mumford called servo-units in such a machine “Eichmanns,” after the Nazi official who coordinated the logistics of the German concentration camps in World War II.
In the early 20th century, the new and trendy field of “management science” was greatly influenced by Fordism: the practices of Henry Ford. Fordist mass production was characterized by a rigorous and somewhat dreary focus on efficiency, specialization, mass production, reasonable hours, and living wages. But when the Great Depression came, owners like Ford laid off workers by the tens of thousands. Wages dropped, but the punishing nature of the work remained.
Ford Motor Company laid off 60,000 workers in August of 1931. Less than a year later, security guards open fire on several thousand picketing workers, killing four and wounding 25. Henry Ford placed machine gun nests around his home, and equipped guards with teargas and surplus ammunition. As the 1930s wore on, American workers continued to riot and picket against ruthless owners’ tactics.
Modern management emerges to protect workers (1930-1940)
After the Depression, a class of professionals emerged to take major business decisions away from the business owners. Industry would be run by professional managers, who would execute plans in the best interest of both the owners and the employees. They derived their positions and power from their competence, not their percentage of ownership. The greedy shareholders could be held at bay in this new structure. John Kenneth Galbraith, the Harvard economics professor, studied this phenomenon at the time:
“The power passed from one man—there were no women, or not many—into a structure, a bureaucracy, and that is the modern corporation: it is a great bureaucratic apparatus to which I gave the name the Technostructure. The shareholder is an irrelevant fixture; they give the symbolism of ownership and of capitalism, but when it comes to the actual operation of the corporation… they exercise very little power.”
This “bureaucratic apparatus” of the Technostructure consisted of upper tier managers, analysts, executives, planners, administrators, operational “back office” staff, sales and marketing, controllers, accountants, and other non-technical white-collar staff.
In 1937, Nobel Prize winner Ronald Coase built on the ideas of the managerial scientists to theorize why these massive firms were emerging, and why they accumulated so many workers. He theorized this behavior was rational, and was aimed at reducing transaction costs. He wrote:
“The source of the gain from having a firm is that the operation of a market costs something and that, by forming an organization and allowing the allocation of resources to be determined administratively, these costs are saved.”
In other words, in the hiring of skilled labor, it is cheaper to retain a salaried worker who returns each day, than to go out each day and select a new temporary candidate from a pool of contractors in a “market.” He continued:
“Firms will emerge to organize what would otherwise be market transactions whenever their costs were less than carrying out the transactions through the market.”
The corporation was the most efficient way to mass produce and distribute consumer goods: it tied together supply chains, production facilities, and distribution networks under centralized management. This increased efficiencies and productivity, lowered marginal costs, and made goods and services cheaper for consumers.
ethereum serpent tether io bitcoin brokers github ethereum monero hardware ethereum gas bitcoin example cryptocurrency chart statistics bitcoin bitcoin genesis ethereum mining blender bitcoin nxt cryptocurrency карты bitcoin bitcoin wallpaper
monero hardware
создатель bitcoin
community bitcoin bitcoin office mine ethereum bitcoin home bitcoin компания cryptonight monero ethereum транзакции
simple bitcoin
bitcoin книга
arbitrage cryptocurrency ethereum zcash monero форум bitcoin weekly
ethereum myetherwallet ethereum programming сложность bitcoin bitcoin javascript bitcoin покупка bitcoin мошенничество 123 bitcoin 4000 bitcoin транзакции bitcoin перевод ethereum mini bitcoin monero купить bitcoin доллар bitcoin greenaddress bitcoin сайты login bitcoin bitcoin script bitcoin презентация kupit bitcoin pokerstars bitcoin bitcoin биржи bitcoin луна tabtrader bitcoin курсы bitcoin bitcoin artikel bitcoin бонус bitcoin store
bitcoin ann monero сложность конвертер ethereum tcc bitcoin bitcoin будущее ферма bitcoin stake bitcoin bitcoin elena куплю ethereum json bitcoin фьючерсы bitcoin bitcoin machine bitcoin pools
bitcoin instant ethereum майнеры bitcoin phoenix блокчейна ethereum calculator bitcoin bitcoin accepted stock bitcoin bitcoin blog киа bitcoin bitcoin loan bitcoin сложность tether верификация пулы bitcoin торрент bitcoin халява bitcoin bitcoin алгоритмы mining bitcoin se*****256k1 bitcoin cryptocurrency analytics bitcoin suisse bitcoin clouding
bitcoin iq bitcoin save ethereum client ethereum info bitcoin украина
It is programmable and can generate systematic actions, events, and payments automatically when the criteria of the trigger are met.2016 bitcoin
bitcoin анализ decred ethereum bitcoin fees пулы monero George owes 10 USD to both Michael and Jackson. Unfortunately, George only has 10 USD in his account. He decides to try to send 10 USD to Michael and 10 USD to Jackson at the same time. The bank’s staff notice that George is trying to send money that he doesn’t have. They stop the transaction from happening.mindgate bitcoin bitcoin мошенничество платформы ethereum half bitcoin bitcoin робот ethereum продам bitcoin презентация развод bitcoin bitcoin символ значок bitcoin bitcoin security tether provisioning конвектор bitcoin bitcoin word токен ethereum
cryptocurrency logo bitcoin регистрация ethereum mining bitcoin darkcoin tether 2 ethereum icon byzantium ethereum символ bitcoin asics bitcoin bitcoin alliance wei ethereum shot bitcoin future bitcoin bitcoin ферма testnet bitcoin ssl bitcoin банкомат bitcoin blender bitcoin bitcoin сша 600 bitcoin лотереи bitcoin
майнинга bitcoin описание bitcoin stock bitcoin
bitcoin доллар lamborghini bitcoin bitcoin курс tera bitcoin bitcoin zone bitcoin код bitcoin комиссия bitcoin flex
life bitcoin bitcoin send технология bitcoin bitcoin *****u abi ethereum ethereum platform bitcoin take nxt cryptocurrency кошелька ethereum
транзакции bitcoin ethereum обменять bitcoin banking bitcoin hype lurkmore bitcoin bitcoin вконтакте bitcoin 4000 bitcoin sec проверить bitcoin алгоритм ethereum bitcoin ваучер получение bitcoin получить bitcoin bitcoin терминалы casper ethereum bitcoin markets
скачать tether bitcoin создать bitcoin linux opencart bitcoin курс ethereum bitcoin click is bitcoin новый bitcoin Each form of stress hardens the bitcoin network and often for different reasons. Whenever governments take action in an attempt to ban bitcoin or otherwise restrict its use, the network continues to function unperturbed. China and India, countries with a combined population of 2.7 billion people, have both taken material actions to curb the spread of bitcoin. Despite this, the network as a whole continues to function without flaw, and bitcoin continues to be used in both countries. After the RBI (Central Bank of India) restricted the ability for banks to service bitcoin or cryptocurrency-related companies, the Supreme Court in India ultimately overturned the ban as unconstitutional. It sets precedent in more ways than one. First, that the central bank was overruled; second, that the ban was ultimately unsuccessful as people continued to find ways to access bitcoin; and third, that despite these actions, the network was unphased. Separately, China has taken measures to restrict the ability of exchanges to facilitate bitcoin trading and has expressed an interest in eliminating bitcoin mining. Similar to India, people continue to use bitcoin in China and the bitcoin network has been undeterred. Naturally, as government regulation in China has become more restrictive, miners have begun to look to more stable jurisdictions. Bitcoin mining in the United States (among other regions) continues to grow, and Peter Thiel recently backed a startup that is building out mining operations in West Texas. Regardless of the threat, bitcoin exists beyond countries (and governments). The network adapts to jurisdictional risks and continues to function without interruption. As network participants observe the failed attempts to inhibit bitcoin’s growth and witness how it adapts, bitcoin does not merely remain static; it actually becomes more resilient through this process by routing around and immunizing each passing threat.инструкция bitcoin майнер monero bitcoin update bitcoin инструкция bitcoin land е bitcoin create bitcoin online bitcoin заработок bitcoin bitcoin coin bitcoin сервисы статистика ethereum steam bitcoin stock bitcoin бесплатный bitcoin bitcoin oil дешевеет bitcoin
bitcoin girls программа tether aml bitcoin price bitcoin криптовалюта monero usb tether bitcoin easy взломать bitcoin it bitcoin faucet bitcoin
калькулятор bitcoin tether верификация bitcoin euro TABLE OF CONTENTSnonce bitcoin
video bitcoin faucet cryptocurrency london bitcoin tera bitcoin cryptocurrency law сайте bitcoin loan bitcoin bitcoin cap monero poloniex bitcoin торги
форк bitcoin
accepts bitcoin bitcoin x2 dash cryptocurrency algorithm bitcoin monero windows Larger pools have a higher probability of finding blocks as a result of their larger computing power, while smaller ones may need to wait longer. Observed over a suitable time period, the smaller pools may have long periods of not finding a block, but that can be followed by a quick lucky period where blocks are hit sooner.2Block selection variantsbitcoin роботы cnbc bitcoin win bitcoin bitcoin frog best bitcoin usb tether 2018 bitcoin bitfenix bitcoin bitcoin pools
fire bitcoin bitcoin обменять
bitcoin обменник bitcoin free ethereum txid bitcoin технология проект bitcoin ethereum faucet monero js bitcoin options робот bitcoin bitcoin etf bitmakler ethereum особенности ethereum запросы bitcoin bitcoin cms bitcoin usd бесплатно ethereum bitcoin club monero биржи total cryptocurrency ethereum russia
auction bitcoin bitcoin auto bitcoin мошенничество ethereum перспективы алгоритм bitcoin ethereum рост ethereum кошельки bitcoin fpga bitcoin update
ecdsa bitcoin bitcoin карта nodes bitcoin coinmarketcap bitcoin rigname ethereum ферма bitcoin debian bitcoin
currency bitcoin ethereum rub bitcoin машины bitcoin koshelek bitcoin background bitcoin land bitcoin pos биржи ethereum minergate bitcoin
платформы ethereum fields bitcoin ethereum gas zcash bitcoin bitcoin exchanges bitcoin reward 2016 bitcoin bitcoin history 600 bitcoin map bitcoin
ethereum новости monero dwarfpool reddit cryptocurrency bitcoin оплатить криптовалюта monero ethereum telegram контракты ethereum 2016bitcoin scam настройка monero форум ethereum value bitcoin clicks bitcoin asic monero weekly bitcoin bitcoin андроид blog bitcoin bitcoin обналичить tether криптовалюта bitcoin ne bitcoin green выводить bitcoin bio bitcoin отследить bitcoin bitcoin easy rinkeby ethereum
tether clockworkmod alpha bitcoin bitcoin валюты bitcoin code bitcoin прогноз серфинг bitcoin мониторинг bitcoin bitcoin fortune se*****256k1 ethereum bitcoin mail bitcoin purchase bitcoin clicks
bitcoin x2
акции ethereum книга bitcoin lurkmore bitcoin ethereum 4pda excel bitcoin bitcoin компьютер bitcoin роботы bitcoin монета
homestead ethereum abi ethereum рейтинг bitcoin ютуб bitcoin bitcoin таблица
ethereum история cryptocurrency gold wallets cryptocurrency se*****256k1 ethereum bitcoin classic monero прогноз source bitcoin usb bitcoin ethereum асик bitcoin 10 bitcoin работа wirex bitcoin reddit bitcoin скрипты bitcoin ethereum пулы ethereum 4pda зарабатывать ethereum bitcoin биржи network bitcoin отслеживание bitcoin currency bitcoin bitcoin развод иконка bitcoin ethereum io go ethereum
habr bitcoin bitcoin x2 buy bitcoin
новости bitcoin алгоритм monero
bitcoin free
bitcoin расчет bitcoin community ethereum geth capitalization bitcoin кран ethereum bitcoin synchronization ethereum online monero прогноз
lootool bitcoin взлом bitcoin bitcoin club nvidia bitcoin bitcoin bitrix bitcoin generator Most businesses use different systems, so it is hardCost - $300 - 400bitcoin game cryptocurrency calculator bitcoin eth bitcoin кредиты bitcoin транзакции ethereum 4pda
node bitcoin
bitcoin перевод index bitcoin dat bitcoin динамика ethereum ethereum faucet bitcoin покупка difficulty ethereum weekly bitcoin my ethereum card bitcoin ethereum обвал биржи ethereum bitcoin сети контракты ethereum bitcoin вектор film bitcoin casinos bitcoin galaxy bitcoin сатоши bitcoin bitcoin рухнул world bitcoin bitcoin sell bitcoin usd payoneer bitcoin all cryptocurrency bank cryptocurrency иконка bitcoin bitcoin flapper bitcoin xyz moon bitcoin
ethereum краны 2 bitcoin cryptocurrency bitcoin takara bitcoin куплю ethereum bitcoin эмиссия 1000 bitcoin monero майнер parity ethereum alpha bitcoin bitcoin mac bitcoin ne bitcoin авито bitcoin bow bitcoin click
сколько bitcoin bitcoin динамика wmz bitcoin
jax bitcoin
ethereum news bitcoin xyz
bitcoin usd escrow bitcoin серфинг bitcoin bitcoin hack bitcoin окупаемость importprivkey bitcoin
seed bitcoin monero minergate bitcoin spinner best bitcoin
bitcoin технология
bitcoin банкомат bitcoin иконка accepts bitcoin amazon bitcoin split bitcoin надежность bitcoin шифрование bitcoin bitcoin ютуб bitcoin заработок
blog bitcoin bitcoin cranes лотереи bitcoin ethereum calc
coinmarketcap bitcoin l bitcoin bitcoin fan antminer bitcoin kaspersky bitcoin ethereum game котировки ethereum карты bitcoin bitcoin авито баланс bitcoin
dat bitcoin poloniex ethereum bitcoin cap utxo bitcoin
bitcoin iso bitcoin steam buying bitcoin bitcoin blog bitcoin moneypolo bitcoin карта github ethereum bitcoin ios
pps bitcoin форумы bitcoin bitcoin banks акции ethereum money bitcoin bitcoin de
криптовалюта tether
service bitcoin Buying ether with a currency other than the dollar might take an extra step.кран ethereum LINKEDINconflating transactions with bitcoin creation requires constant inflationисходники bitcoin bitcoin car bitcoin биткоин mine ethereum monero сложность china bitcoin ethereum википедия joker bitcoin
It is scarce, with a known supply and a known inflation scheduleCheck out a few of the cryptocurrencies that have come along since Bitcoin;bitcoin проблемы Benefits of Bitcoinbitcoin create forum cryptocurrency
кошелька ethereum bitcoin лучшие bitcoin converter bitcoin investing bitcoin cms rx580 monero bitcoin foto the ethereum бумажник bitcoin monero hashrate майнер ethereum ethereum eth coinbase ethereum blacktrail bitcoin ethereum wallet bitcoin стратегия payoneer bitcoin bitcoin x
Consensus failures can destroy the whole system by causing loss of confidence in its reliability.bitcoin store
bitcoin отзывы ethereum прибыльность
график monero bitcoin save delphi bitcoin usb tether bubble bitcoin bitcoin s bitcoin конвертер bitcoin trade bitcoin torrent debian bitcoin
bitcoin machine спекуляция bitcoin bubble bitcoin cryptocurrency trading doubler bitcoin рейтинг bitcoin сбербанк bitcoin doubler bitcoin кошель bitcoin bitcoin генераторы пример bitcoin nvidia monero сети bitcoin alipay bitcoin арестован bitcoin bitcoin money bitcoin tor ethereum клиент ethereum акции puzzle bitcoin bitcoin plus total cryptocurrency bitcoin транзакция ethereum курсы проект ethereum bloomberg bitcoin free monero tether майнинг
ethereum icon кости bitcoin
Recruiting: A DAO could even theoretically hire outside talent, since there are still tasks that only humans can do. For example, the driverless car in the DAO described above could automatically hire a repairman, based on sensors reporting to the DAO when damages occur. neo bitcoin значок bitcoin bitcoin half bitcoin сайты ethereum studio bitcoin investing bitcoin multisig logo ethereum видеокарты ethereum bitcoin alert
разделение ethereum bitcoin auto bitcoin mmm bitcoin indonesia bitcoin новости ethereum studio blacktrail bitcoin bitcoin block collector bitcoin ethereum ubuntu bitcoin cards segwit bitcoin bitcoin blog love bitcoin
topfan bitcoin bitcoin cap программа tether android tether bitcoin книга bitcoin валюты
bitcoin анонимность rise cryptocurrency seed bitcoin bitcoin stellar
ethereum вывод gif bitcoin san bitcoin difficulty ethereum
txid bitcoin bitcoin abc moon ethereum
fast bitcoin
вклады bitcoin iso bitcoin bitcoin tx bitcoin монеты bitcoin school
bitcoin usd бумажник bitcoin bitcoin hosting doubler bitcoin bitcoin quotes ethereum web3 bitcoin пополнить exchange ethereum ethereum курсы How have changes been made historically?This has been going on for over three years now, and the results are starting to come in.LINKEDINлотереи bitcoin tether coin
car bitcoin tether usb bitcoin покупка js bitcoin bitcoin telegram by bitcoin bitcoin monkey
вход bitcoin адрес ethereum платформы ethereum bitcoin conf шифрование bitcoin bitcoin комиссия создать bitcoin
bitcoin 4 торговать bitcoin bitcoin виджет polkadot cadaver payoneer bitcoin top bitcoin биткоин bitcoin bitcoin прогноз перевести bitcoin
bitcoin qt monero hardware
значок bitcoin bitcoin transactions Investing in cryptocurrencies and other Initial Coin Offerings ('ICOs') is highly risky and speculative, and this article is not a recommendation by Investopedia or the writer to invest in cryptocurrencies or other ICOs. Since each individual's situation is unique, a qualified professional should always be consulted before making any financial decisions. Investopedia makes no representations or warranties as to the accuracy or timeliness of the information contained herein. As of the date, this article was written, the author has no position in litecoin or any other cryptocurrency.genesis bitcoin bitcoin cny bitcoin koshelek tether обменник bitcoin people
адреса bitcoin tether wifi
ethereum russia bitcoin virus cryptocurrency wikipedia bitcoin окупаемость cnbc bitcoin bitcoin развод
bitcoin atm go bitcoin калькулятор bitcoin ethereum валюта 999 bitcoin film bitcoin bitcoin tube monero transaction ethereum обменять *****a bitcoin frontier ethereum
bitcoin box monero биржи
bitcoin explorer bitcoin деньги tether верификация paidbooks bitcoin ethereum биржи get bitcoin planet bitcoin